Practical legal guidance for international clients in Spain

Can I Choose My National Law to Govern My Inheritance in Spain?

This is an important estate-planning question for foreign nationals living in Spain or owning property or other assets here.

And, in many cases, the answer is yes. Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 allows a person to choose the law of the State whose nationality he or she possesses to govern the succession as a whole. This choice of law, known in private international law as professio iuris, can be particularly important for foreign nationals who live in Spain but want their succession to be governed by their national inheritance law.

However, the choice is subject to specific legal requirements and its consequences should be carefully considered. Choosing your national succession law does not mean choosing any law you prefer, does not necessarily determine which country’s authorities will deal with the succession and does not determine the tax treatment of the inheritance.

Can I Choose My National Law for Inheritance in Spain Raquel Yepes International Inheritance Lawyer Málaga Costa del Sol

Key Takeaways

  • Under Article 22 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, you may choose the law of a State whose nationality you possess to govern your succession as a whole.
  • You must possess that nationality either when the choice is made or at the time of death.
  • If you have more than one nationality, you may choose the law of any State whose nationality you possess at either of those times.
  • You cannot simply choose any country’s inheritance law because it is more favourable.
  • The choice must be made expressly in a disposition of property upon death or be demonstrated by the terms of such a disposition.
  • The chosen law generally governs the succession as a whole, including assets situated in Spain and abroad.
  • A choice of national law can affect beneficiaries, reserved shares, testamentary freedom, liability for succession debts and the distribution of the estate.
  • Choosing foreign succession law does not eliminate Spanish Inheritance Tax or other Spanish tax obligations that may apply.
  • Choice of applicable law and international jurisdiction are related but legally distinct questions.

1. What Law Normally Governs an International Inheritance in Spain?

Before considering whether you should choose your national law for inheritance in Spain, it is important to understand what would happen if no choice were made.

Article 21 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 establishes the general rule that the succession as a whole is governed by the law of the State in which the deceased had his or her habitual residence at the time of death.

There is an exceptional rule where it is clear from all the circumstances that, at the time of death, the deceased was manifestly more closely connected with another State. However, this is an exception and should not be treated as a substitute for proper succession planning.

Consequently, nationality is not automatically the principal connecting factor under the Regulation. For a foreign national habitually resident in Spain at death, Spanish succession law may in principle become applicable unless a valid choice of national law has been made or another provision of the Regulation leads to a different result.

For a broader overview of the legal framework applicable to inheritance in Spain for foreigners, including applicable law, taxation and the administration of international estates, you can read my general guide to inheritance in Spain.

2. Can I Choose My National Law for Inheritance in Spain?

Yes, provided that the requirements of Article 22 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 are satisfied.

A person may choose the law of the State whose nationality he or she possesses at the time of making the choice or at the time of death to govern the succession as a whole.

This is an important estate-planning mechanism for internationally mobile individuals. A person may live for many years in Spain while maintaining a different nationality and may prefer the succession to be governed by the law with which he or she is more familiar.

The choice must nevertheless be legally available and properly expressed. It should not be assumed merely because a foreign national has made a will under the law of his or her country of nationality.

3. Can I Choose Any Foreign Law?

No. Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 deliberately restricts the freedom to choose the applicable law. The testator cannot simply select the inheritance law of whichever country appears to provide the most advantageous succession rules.

The choice is limited to the law of a State whose nationality the person possesses either when making the choice or at the time of death.

The purpose of this restriction is to ensure a genuine connection between the person planning the succession and the law selected.

For example, residence in a country, ownership of property there or family connections with that country do not, by themselves, create a right under Article 22 to choose its law.

4. What If I Have More Than One Nationality?

Article 22 expressly addresses multiple nationality.

A person who possesses more than one nationality may choose the law of any of the States whose nationality he or she possesses at the time the choice is made or at the time of death.

This can provide significant planning flexibility for dual or multiple nationals, but the consequences of each possible choice should be examined before the will is drafted.

The question should not simply be which nationality the person considers to be his or her “main” nationality. The Regulation expressly permits a choice between the laws of the relevant States of nationality, subject to the requirements of Article 22.

5. Does the Chosen Law Have to Be the Law of an EU Member State?

No; and this is particularly important for British, American, Canadian and all other non-EU nationals with connections to Spain.

Article 20 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 establishes the principle of universal application. This means that a law designated by the Regulation is to be applied whether or not it is the law of an EU Member State.

A British national, for example, is not prevented from choosing the relevant law of his or her nationality merely because the United Kingdom is not bound by Regulation (EU) No 650/2012. Where a Spanish authority applies the Regulation, Article 20 allows the Regulation to designate the law of a third State.

The precise law applicable within a State containing several territorial legal systems may require a further analysis under Article 36 of the Regulation and the relevant internal conflict-of-laws rules.

6.How Do I Choose My National Law?

Article 22 does not permit an informal choice made simply by telling relatives which law you would like to apply.

The choice must be made expressly in a declaration in the form of a disposition of property upon death, or it must be demonstrated by the terms of such a disposition.

In practice, where a foreign national wishes to make a deliberate choice of law, it is generally preferable for the will or other relevant succession instrument to contain a clear and express choice rather than leaving the issue to be inferred after death.

The wording should identify the law selected and should be drafted consistently with the overall succession plan.

7. Can the Choice of Law Be Implied?

Potentially, yes, but relying on an implied choice can create unnecessary uncertainty.

Article 22 provides that the choice may either be express or be demonstrated by the terms of a disposition of property upon death.

Recital 39 of the Regulation explains that a choice might, for example, be demonstrated where the deceased referred in the disposition to specific provisions of the law of the State of his or her nationality or otherwise mentioned that law.

However, whether the terms of a particular will are sufficient to demonstrate a choice can become contentious after death.

Where the intention is genuinely to choose national law, an express and carefully drafted choice is therefore normally preferable.

8. Does the Choice Apply Only to My Property in Spain?

No. This is one of the most important features of the European Succession Regulation.

The law chosen under Article 22 governs the succession as a whole. The Regulation is designed, as far as possible, to avoid fragmentation of the succession merely because assets are situated in different countries.

Accordingly, a choice of national law should not normally be drafted on the assumption that it governs only a villa, apartment or bank account situated in Spain.

This is particularly important for people who own assets in several jurisdictions. Before choosing a law, the entire estate and the possible interaction with third-country legal systems should be considered.

9. What Does the Chosen Succession Law Govern?

Article 23 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 gives the applicable succession law a broad scope.

Among other matters, it governs:

  • the determination of the beneficiaries;
  • their respective shares in the estate;
  • succession rights of the surviving spouse or partner;
  • capacity to inherit;
  • disinheritance and disqualification by conduct;
  • the transfer of assets, rights and obligations to heirs and legatees;
  • the conditions and effects of acceptance or waiver of the succession or a legacy;
  • the powers of heirs, executors and other administrators of the estate;
  • liability for succession debts;
  • the disposable part of the estate;
  • reserved shares and other restrictions on testamentary freedom;
  • certain obligations concerning gifts, advancements or legacies when calculating beneficiaries’ shares; and
  • the sharing-out of the estate.

The decision to choose national law can therefore have substantial consequences. It is not simply a formal clause inserted into a will.

10. Can Choosing My National Law Affect Spanish Forced Heirship Rules?

Potentially, yes, and this is one of the reasons why the choice of law can be particularly significant.

Article 23 expressly provides that the applicable succession law governs the disposable part of the estate, reserved shares and other restrictions on the disposal of property upon death.

Therefore, where a valid choice under Article 22 results in foreign succession law governing the succession, questions concerning reserved shares or other limitations on testamentary freedom will generally be determined under that chosen succession law rather than simply by assuming that the Spanish Civil Code rules apply because assets are situated in Spain.

However, the consequences should be analysed under the particular chosen law. Choosing national law should never be treated as a generic mechanism for “avoiding Spanish forced heirship”. The chosen law becomes the law governing the succession and must be applied as such, with its own rules, restrictions and protections.

11. Does Choosing My National Law Avoid Spanish Inheritance Tax?

No. And the distinction is fundamental, because Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 governs civil-law aspects of international succession, and Article 1 expressly excludes revenue, customs and administrative matters from its scope.

Choosing your national law for inheritance in Spain therefore does not amount to choosing the tax law applicable to the inheritance. Spanish Inheritance Tax may still apply according to Spanish tax legislation, depending on matters such as the residence of the deceased or heir and the location of the assets.

Similarly, Spanish real estate may give rise to other Spanish tax or municipal obligations irrespective of the succession law selected in the will.

Succession planning and inheritance tax planning are therefore connected in practice but legally distinct exercises.

12. Does Choosing My National Law Mean That Courts in My Country Will Deal With the Inheritance?

Not automatically. Applicable law and international jurisdiction are different private international law questions.

Under Article 4 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, the general jurisdiction rule gives jurisdiction to the courts of the Member State in which the deceased had his or her habitual residence at the time of death.

A choice of law under Article 22 does not, by itself, automatically transfer jurisdiction to the courts of the State whose law has been chosen.

Where the chosen law is the law of a Member State bound by the Regulation, Articles 5 to 7 contain mechanisms which, subject to their requirements, may allow the courts of that Member State to acquire jurisdiction, including in certain circumstances through a choice-of-court agreement between the parties concerned.

The distinction is important: choosing the law is not the same as choosing the court.

13. What Happens If I Choose the Law of a Non-EU Country?

The Regulation can designate the law of a third State because of its universal application.

There is, however, an important technical consequence when that law has been chosen under Article 22.

Article 34 regulates renvoi, the mechanism through which the private international law rules of a third State may in certain circumstances refer the matter back to another legal system. However, Article 34(2) expressly excludes renvoi where the applicable law has been chosen under Article 22.

Accordingly, where a Spanish authority applies a third-country law validly chosen under Article 22, the reference is to the substantive succession rules of the chosen law rather than to its conflict-of-laws rules for the purpose of renvoi.

This can be particularly relevant in estates involving nationals of non-EU States and assets situated in Spain.

14. Special Care Where a Country Has More Than One Succession Law

Some States contain several territorial units with their own succession laws. This means that simply referring to the law of a person’s nationality may not always complete the analysis.

Article 36 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 deals with States comprising several territorial units, each with its own rules of succession law.

As a first step, the internal conflict-of-laws rules of that State determine which territorial unit’s law applies. Where no such internal rules exist, the Regulation provides additional connecting rules.

This issue can be particularly important when planning the succession of nationals of States with multiple territorial legal systems. The precise legal system selected by the choice-of-law clause should therefore be examined rather than assumed.

15. Can I Change or Revoke My Choice of Law?

Yes, subject to the applicable requirements.

Article 22 provides that modification or revocation of the choice must comply with the formal requirements applicable to the modification or revocation of a disposition of property upon death.

Furthermore, the substantive validity of the act by which the choice of law is made is governed by the chosen law.

A change of will should therefore be reviewed not only to ensure that the testamentary dispositions themselves achieve the intended result, but also to determine whether an earlier choice of law is being maintained, modified or revoked.

16. What If My Will Was Made Before 17 August 2015?

Older wills require particular care.

Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 applies to the succession of persons who die on or after 17 August 2015, but Article 83 contains transitional provisions dealing with choices of law and dispositions made before that date.

A choice of law made before 17 August 2015 may still be valid if it satisfies the conditions established by the Regulation or the relevant private international law rules identified in Article 83.

In addition, where a disposition of property upon death made before 17 August 2015 was made in accordance with a law that the deceased could have chosen under the Regulation, Article 83(4) provides, subject to its terms, that that law is deemed to have been chosen as the law applicable to the succession.

It is therefore unwise to assume that an older foreign or Spanish will is ineffective simply because it predates the application of the Regulation. Its wording and legal context should be examined individually.

17. Does a Choice of National Law Override Every Spanish Rule?

No.

Although the law selected under Article 22 has a broad scope, the Regulation itself contains limits and exclusions.

Tax matters fall outside its scope. The nature of rights in rem and the requirements and effects of registration of rights in property registers are also excluded from the Regulation’s scope.

Article 30 additionally preserves certain special rules of the State where particular immovable property, enterprises or other special categories of assets are situated where those rules impose restrictions concerning or affecting succession for economic, family or social considerations and apply irrespective of the law governing the succession.

Finally, Article 35 allows the application of a provision of the otherwise applicable law to be refused where its application would be manifestly incompatible with the public policy (ordre public) of the forum.

A choice-of-law clause should therefore be understood within the complete framework of the Regulation rather than as an unlimited power to displace every rule applicable in Spain.

18. Should Every Foreign National Living in Spain Choose Their National Law?

It depends. The existence of a right to choose national law does not mean that exercising it is always the best succession-planning decision.

The appropriate choice depends on the person’s family circumstances, nationality or nationalities, habitual residence, location and nature of the assets, existing wills, matrimonial property regime and succession objectives.

In some cases, the national law may provide greater testamentary freedom. In others, it may contain its own reserved-share rules, family protections or succession mechanisms that produce consequences the testator did not anticipate.

The legal consequences should therefore be compared before the choice is made.

19. Why Is an Express Choice of Law Important for Foreign Residents in Spain?

International lives change. A person may make a will while living in one country, subsequently move to Spain, acquire Spanish property, marry or divorce, have children or acquire assets in several jurisdictions.

Because habitual residence at death is the general connecting factor under Article 21, changes in a person’s life may affect which law would apply in the absence of a valid choice.

An appropriately drafted choice of national law can provide greater predictability by identifying in advance the succession law that the testator intends to govern the estate.

That predictability is one of the principal objectives underlying the choice-of-law mechanism contained in Regulation (EU) No 650/2012.

20. Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing National Law for Inheritance in Spain

Can a British national choose English law for an inheritance involving Spain?

A British national may make a choice under Article 22 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of the law corresponding to his or her nationality, subject to the need to identify correctly the relevant legal system where the State comprises several territorial legal systems. The fact that the United Kingdom is not bound by the Regulation does not prevent a Spanish authority from applying a third-country law designated under the Regulation.

Can an American choose US law to govern an inheritance in Spain?

Article 22 permits a choice of the law of the State of nationality, and Article 20 gives the Regulation universal application. However, where a State contains several territorial legal systems, further analysis under Article 36 may be required to determine the relevant territorial law.

Can I choose Spanish law if I am not Spanish?

Not under Article 22 merely because you live in Spain or own property here. A choice under Article 22 is limited to the law of a State whose nationality you possess at the time of the choice or at death. Spanish law may nevertheless apply under the habitual-residence rule of Article 21 where its requirements are satisfied.

Does choosing my national law apply only to my Spanish property?

No. A valid choice under Article 22 is a choice of law governing the succession as a whole. It should not be understood simply as a choice applying exclusively to Spanish real estate.

Can choosing my national law prevent Spanish forced heirship rules from applying?

The law governing the succession determines reserved shares and other restrictions on testamentary freedom under Article 23. A valid choice of foreign national law can therefore be highly relevant to these issues, but its actual consequences depend on the substantive rules of the chosen law and the complete circumstances of the succession.

Will choosing my national law reduce Spanish Inheritance Tax?

Not by itself. Taxation is outside the scope of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012. Spanish Inheritance Tax must be analysed separately under the applicable Spanish tax legislation.

Do I need to make the choice in my will?

The choice must be made expressly in a declaration in the form of a disposition of property upon death or be demonstrated by the terms of such a disposition. Where a deliberate choice is intended, expressing it clearly in the relevant testamentary instrument can reduce uncertainty after death.

What happens if I do not choose any law?

The general rule in Article 21 applies: the succession as a whole is governed by the law of the State in which the deceased had his or her habitual residence at the time of death, subject to the exceptional manifestly-closer-connection rule and the other provisions of the Regulation.

21. Legal Advice on Choosing the Law Applicable to an Inheritance in Spain

As in so many areas of law, prevention is usually far easier than trying to solve a problem once it has already arisen. In international succession matters, a carefully drafted choice of law can provide greater certainty, reduce the risk of disputes and help ensure that your estate is dealt with in accordance with your wishes.

If you own assets in Spain or have connections with more than one country, it is advisable to review your succession planning before it becomes urgent. A will drafted without considering the applicable succession law can create unnecessary complications for your heirs.

Good succession planning is not about predicting every possible problem. It is about avoiding the ones that can be prevented.

👉 Request legal advice

Related posts